As diesel prices spike, free public transport and bike hire can be beneficial for commuters’ health and their finances

World



KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Today, 17 million French people are struggling financially to get from A to B: to control spending on fuel some are refraining from making a medical appointment or seeing their loved ones while others cut back on essential expenses. A phenomenon aggravated by the current price hikes.

  • In France, 74% of the active population drive to work, even though half of them live less than 9 km from their workplace. For the most financially challenged, free transport, whether public transport or free or subsidised bike hire, can be a good way to get around soaring prices at the pump.

  • Internationally, studies show that free transport can improve commuters’ health and even generate health savings at the collective level.


With the Strait of Hormuz crisis, fuel prices reached record levels. This pressure is most certainly not a passing phase: as early as 2021, a report commissioned by the French Ministry of the Armed Forces estimated that Europe’s oil supply could fall by up to 20% over the course of 2030 compared to 2019, regardless of geopolitical tensions.

This increase weighs on commuters who rely on their cars, but it hits the most vulnerable hardest. According to the Mobility Barometer designed by Wimoov, a French nonprofit organisation that helps people facing transport barriers access sustainable and inclusive daily mobility, 17 million French people, nearly one in three adults, are experiencing ‘mobility precariousness’, primarily financial difficulties in getting around. Many end up abandoning a medical appointment, visiting relatives or leisure activities.

Politically, several levers are being debated: reductions in fuel taxes, fuel vouchers, incentives for purchasing electric cars… Free transport, especially for low-income households, could be another. Total or partial, universal or concessions for certain categories, this access most often is applied to public transport, but seldomly to bike hire.

It obviously comes at a price to the community, but unlike a tax cut, it could produce a return on investment via the health benefits it has on the population. It is this hypothesis that we shall examine here.

Travel as a public health determinant

Mobility is a major determinant of health: it conditions access to healthcare, employment, and social connections. It acts through at least two mechanisms.

  • The first is financial. We speak of “constrained motorisation” to refer to low-income households that own a car because there is no alternative. To absorb the cost, some cut back on essential expenses, by skipping meals or switching off heating, at the expense of their health.

  • The second is physical activity. Commuting on foot or by bike (e-bikes included), active mobility provides physical activity with documented benefits for physical and mental health.

In France, cycling, which is quite low compared to other European Union countries, would prevent about 2,000 deaths and 6,000 cases of chronic diseases per year, or savings of nearly 200 millions for France’s public health system. Developing cycling means both improving the health of the population and reducing collective health expenses.

Free transport, a lever for public health?

Alternatives to car use must be accessible to everyone, starting with low-income households that have no other choice than driving. Entirely free or subsidised transport is one way of achieving this.

Its health impact is starting to be documented. A literature review published in 2025 identified 28 studies on the effects of free transport, half of which were British and mostly focused on public transport. It includes the two mechanisms described above (reducing travel-related financial stress and increasing physical activity), in addition to better access to care and reducing social isolation. In England, free bus travel for the elderly has been linked to decreased symptoms of depression.

However, these results must be nuanced: they mainly concern the elderly and young people. Incidentally, experimental studies that would allow these effects to be attributed with certainty to free access to transport remain rare.

As for travelling by car, free access for all sometimes reduces the use of this means of transport less than one might hope, because it attracts some of its new users among pedestrians and cyclists.

In Montpellier (Hérault), free public transport is being presented by elected officials as an instrument to improve the purchasing power of the middle and working classes.
Shutterstock France (no reuse)
  • In Dunkirk, where bus travel has been free since 2018, attendance multiplied by 1.7 in the first year, but only 8% of respondents said they had stopped using their car.

  • In Germany, the monthly fee of 9 euros for the summer of 2022 increased rail travel by about 35%, but reduced car traffic by only 1-5%.

These examples show that, until now, general free transportation has not greatly reduced car use: its interest lies mainly in what it brings to commuters, who have fewer options for getting around. However, these measures were assessed when fuel was cheaper than it is today, or when prices were lower due to tax cuts. If prices remain persistently high, the shift towards alternatives could be more pronounced.

But free access is useless where there is no demand: during the 2022 price increase, people living in rural areas more often gave up certain journeys than people in cities and took public transport much less often (3% versus 10%).

Cycling, another possible free option that is yet to be studied

Free or subsidised conventional or electric bike hire or membership plans could meet these limits.

The potential is real: 74% of employees go to work by car, even though half of them live less than 9 km from their workplace, which represents about twenty-five minutes on an electrically assisted bicycle. E-bikes make these distances accessible, especially for less athletic people and families, while providing moderate intensity physical activity.

Above all, it can be a credible alternative to car use (especially when weather conditions are favourable) for households that have relatively short daily commutes, in a logic of transport multimodality.

In a recent meta-analysis, our team collected ten studies that measured travel among commuters before and after access to an e-bike. These studies show that, on average, participants cycled 5km more per day and 2.4km less by car. This postponement was all the more pronounced because they used to mainly get around by car, which was particularly the case for households with limited motorisation.

Long perceived as a pursuit for the urban middle classes, cycling is increasingly attracting low-income households. In Rennes (Ille-et-Vilaine), free self-service bicycle subscriptions that are geared towards low-income have increased by 26% in one year, according to data that is yet to be released.

The program Vélo-Égaux, led by the French Federation of Bicycle Users (FUB), has enabled people experiencing financial hardship to have access to at least 4,000 bikes in thirty or so areas, both rural and suburban. Associations like Wimoov also support people in difficulty, notably by bike hire. Yet none of these initiatives have been evaluated in terms of their health impacts.

Spending or investing?

Energy crises can be tipping points. In a meta-analysis of 52 interventions, our team showed that in Europe measures to reduce car use were more effective when petrol was expensive, especially as alternatives existed. Now is a good time to offer alternative transport solutions because fuel prices are high, households are suffering and levers exist.

Supply would still need to be allocated where it is most lacking. The share of roads that are equipped for cyclists reaches 16.7% in major city centres, compared to 8.7% in the suburbs and about 2% in rural towns. Yet, quick and inexpensive solutions do exist: between 61,000 and 325,000 km of small roads in France, especially in rural areas, could be reclassified to give priority to cyclists and pedestrians.

In France, many small roads could be reclassified to improve pedestrians and cyclists’ safety.
Shutterstock France (no reuse)

In major urban areas, the planned express bike networks would offer car alternatives to 1,7 million inhabitants who currently don’t have access to efficient public transport, and would better serve households below the poverty line than the rest of the population. Combined with solidarity-based free access (i.e. according to social criteria or based on income), these facilities would make bicycles, including e-bikes, accessible far beyond city centres.

France’s budget was recently rejected at first reading by the National Assembly. In the meantime, the 2027 presidential election is approaching. Associating free, solidarity-based access with improvements in areas that are least adapted to cycling would be an investment in the short-term health of the most vulnerable and everyone’s health in the long-term.

Poverty continues to gain ground in France: financial hardship related to getting around already affects 17 million people in France, compared to 15 million two years ago, and each new oil shock will topple other households who rely on their cars. Investing in car alternatives today means protecting a growing share of the population tomorrow.


A weekly e-mail in English featuring expertise from scholars and researchers. It provides an introduction to the diversity of research coming out of the continent and considers some of the key issues facing European countries. Get the newsletter!




Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *