Legal Aid Society Files Petition for Release of Oscar Belgal After ICE Shooting Leaves Bullet Lodged in Neck

Human Rights

NEW YORK — Defense attorneys with the Legal Aid Society have filed an emergency federal habeas corpus petition calling for the immediate release of Oscar Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican man currently detained in federal custody with a bullet still lodged in his neck following an enforcement action by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

Belgal was shot by ICE agents on October 8, 2026, in Manhattan’s Marble Hill neighborhood while sitting in his parked car with his five-year-old son in the back seat. He remains in custody at the Metropolitan Detention Center (MDC) in Brooklyn, where his legal team states he is being held in solitary confinement without undergoing necessary medical procedures to remove the projectile.

Allegations of Human Rights Violations and Medical Neglect

According to court filings submitted by the Legal Aid Society, doctors who initially evaluated Belgal instructed that he return for surgical intervention during the week of October 12 to safely extract the bullet. Instead, federal authorities transferred Belgal to MDC Brooklyn.

Attorneys and advocacy groups, including Make the Road New York, assert that his ongoing detention constitutes severe medical neglect and a violation of basic human rights:

  • Unmet Medical Needs: The bullet remains embedded in Belgal’s neck. His defense team reports he suffers from facial numbness on one side, severe hearing loss in his left ear, and has received minimal pain management while incarcerated.
  • Solitary Confinement: Attorneys state Belgal is being held under restrictive isolation conditions at the Brooklyn federal jail complex, exacerbating his physical strain and limiting access to external medical providers.
  • Legal Challenge: The petition contends that detaining an individual in need of urgent surgical care without providing adequate treatment violates constitutional standards and international human rights principles prohibiting cruel and unusual punishment.

Disputed Accounts of the Enforcement Action

The circumstances surrounding the October 8 shooting remain heavily contested between defense attorneys and federal authorities:

  • Defense Account: Legal Aid representatives state Belgal was attempting to move his vehicle after picking up his young son from school when plainclothes agents approached with weapons drawn without clearly identifying themselves. An agent allegedly smashed the driver-side window before multiple rounds were fired into the vehicle, striking Belgal in the neck while his child watched from the rear seat.
  • Department of Homeland Security Response: Officials from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) maintain that Belgal refused orders to exit, accelerated his vehicle into two government cars blocking his path, and drove toward agents, prompting officers to open fire in self-defense. DHS officials stated agents were unaware a minor was in the vehicle and initially characterized the injury as superficial.

Current Legal Status

The Federal Bureau of Prisons declined to comment on individual medical treatment details due to privacy policies, but stated that inmates in its care are provided necessary medical evaluation and access to care.

Public officials and immigrant advocacy groups have joined calls for an independent investigation into the shooting and the immediate transfer of Belgal to an outside medical facility for surgery. The federal court is expected to review the petition for his release in the coming days.

For direct local reporting on the detention conditions and statements from Belgal’s legal team, you can watch Man shot by ICE in NYC enduring deplorable conditions, which provides key context on his current custody status at MDC Brooklyn.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *