Cyber scamming has evolved into a vast and increasingly sophisticated global industry, with new operations emerging across the globe. A recent series of reports highlights the growing trend of human trafficking into so-called “fraud factories”—forced labor centers that use trafficking victims to carry out fraudulent online schemes. Originally centered in Southeast Asia, these operations have expanded globally, fueled by the profits from scams, the exploitation of vulnerable workers, and the collaboration of criminal groups from various regions.
Emergence of Fraud Factories: A Shift from Gambling to Scamming
Fraud factories, sometimes referred to as “scam centers,” trace their origins to the shutdown of gambling operations run by Chinese organized crime groups during the COVID-19 pandemic. With casinos closing, these criminal organizations adapted quickly by repurposing abandoned buildings, such as hotels and casinos, into massive fraud operations. Trafficking victims, often lured by fake job opportunities, are brought to these centers where their passports are confiscated, and they are forced to carry out online fraud activities targeting victims worldwide.
While many victims are job seekers from regions with high unemployment rates and tech-savvy populations, the growth of these scam centers has introduced new geographic areas and trafficking routes. Countries such as Ghana, Peru, and the UAE have reported scam centers operating within their borders, sometimes tied to Chinese-speaking criminal groups. For example, in 2023, law enforcement freed 43 Malaysians from a compound in Peru, which was linked to Taiwanese criminals running a fraud operation. Additionally, Nigerian victims have been rescued from fraud factories in Ghana, which suggests the expanding scope of the problem.
Changing Dynamics and Victim Profiles
As the scale of these operations has increased, so too has the complexity of victim profiles. While earlier scams primarily targeted individuals with basic language skills, there is now a growing demand for those with specialized technical expertise. The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) reports that traffickers are now increasingly seeking individuals with IT skills, such as software developers, digital marketers, and data scientists, to professionalize their operations. Victims with these qualifications are coerced into helping criminal groups develop and integrate advanced technologies like AI into fraud schemes.
The exploitation of these highly skilled individuals marks a disturbing shift in the profile of victims. One case involved a Myanmar computer engineer who was forced to develop AI capabilities for a fraud factory. The engineer described the technology used by the scam center as being more advanced than anything she had ever encountered, underscoring the growing sophistication of these operations. In addition to highly skilled professionals, the exploitation of individuals with basic technological knowledge, who can use platforms like ChatGPT or translation services to craft convincing fraudulent messages, has broadened the pool of potential victims.
Geographic Expansion and New Challenges
While Southeast Asia remains the epicenter of forced labor in fraud factories, the global nature of human trafficking in these operations is increasingly evident. People from over 100 countries have been trafficked into Southeast Asia, with the U.S. Department of State’s 2024 Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report highlighting countries like Ghana, Nigeria, and Brazil as sources of victims. Traffickers are able to leverage connections across borders, working with local criminals in various regions to operate these illegal centers.
In response, law enforcement agencies worldwide are collaborating more closely to track and disrupt these trafficking networks. However, the rapid relocation and adaptation of criminal groups continue to pose a significant challenge. While some scam centers have been shut down, traffickers are adept at evading detection by constantly shifting locations and adopting new tactics. This dynamic requires an ongoing evolution of anti-trafficking strategies.
Collaborative Efforts to Combat Forced Scamming
Efforts to combat forced labor in scam centers are ramping up, with stakeholders from various sectors working together to disrupt these operations. The U.S. Department of State’s 2023 TIP Report emphasized the growing threat posed by cyber scams, acknowledging the scale of the industry, which has turned into a multi-billion-dollar operation over the past few years. The report called for increased international cooperation to tackle the issue.
One promising strategy is the creation of multistakeholder coalitions involving tech companies, NGOs, and law enforcement agencies. These coalitions, such as Tech Against Trafficking, have been instrumental in raising awareness and developing technological tools to detect and combat fraudulent job postings. For example, researchers at MIT have developed machine learning algorithms to help identify online commercial sex ads tied to trafficking operations, and similar techniques are being applied to fraudulent job advertisements.
There is also growing recognition of the need to update anti-trafficking laws to ensure the protection of victims. Laws that penalize individuals for crimes committed as a result of trafficking must be revised to align with the UNODC’s “non-punishment” principle, which mandates that victims should not be penalized for illegal acts they were coerced into committing. Ensuring that trafficking survivors are supported and not criminalized is essential for encouraging cooperation with law enforcement.
Addressing the Root Causes
The scale and profitability of cyber scamming operations are driven in part by the underlying corruption and governance gaps in some Southeast Asian countries. In some instances, profits from these scam centers contribute to the funding of other criminal activities, such as supporting authoritarian regimes like the Myanmar military junta, which has been implicated in widespread human rights abuses. This creates a cycle of impunity, allowing these fraud operations to thrive and evolve.
To dismantle these operations, a multifaceted approach is needed—one that addresses the governance issues that enable these centers to flourish, while also targeting the traffickers, corrupt officials, and facilitators who make these operations possible. International pressure, coupled with stronger legal frameworks, will be crucial in shutting down these fraud factories and preventing further exploitation.
Conclusion
The growing global network of fraud factories illustrates the evolving nature of human trafficking, with increasingly sophisticated techniques and diverse victim profiles. While efforts to combat these operations are expanding, significant challenges remain. Addressing the issue will require continued collaboration between governments, tech companies, law enforcement, and civil society, as well as increased focus on the structural issues that allow these trafficking networks to thrive. Only through coordinated global action can the exploitation of vulnerable individuals in forced cyber scamming operations be effectively halted.
References:
- U.S. Department of State, 2024 Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report.
- United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), Trafficking in Persons and Cyber Crime.
- Cyber Scamming Goes Global: Sourcing Forced Labor for Fraud Factories: https://www.csis.org/analysis/cyber-scamming-goes-global-sourcing-forced-labor-fraud-factories
- INTERPOL, Cybercrime and Trafficking Networks.
- MIT Technology Review, AI in the Fight Against Human Trafficking.
Image by freepik
